Aaron Rodgers and the Steelers: A Calculated Gamble or Desperate Swing?

Getty Images

The Pittsburgh Steelers made headlines this offseason by signing 41-year-old quarterback Aaron Rodgers, a move that has sparked both excitement and skepticism among analysts and fans alike. After being released by the New York Jets in March, Rodgers took time to assess his options before ultimately landing in Pittsburgh, where he is expected to start and lead a team with playoff ambitions. While the decision might seem desperate on the surface, a deeper analysis reveals that it may be a calculated and justified swing, given the team’s context and options. Rodgers, a four-time NFL MVP, is coming off a disappointing 2024 season with the Jets. Statistically, he ranked 25th in QBR with a mark of 48.0 and posted a completion percentage over expectation of -5%, one of the lowest in the league. Although his performance was underwhelming, there is a case to be made that he was still recovering from a torn Achilles suffered in 2023, and he appeared more mobile as the 2024 season progressed. Even with the down year, Rodgers arguably remains the most talented quarterback available to the Steelers. The logic behind Pittsburgh’s move becomes clearer when evaluating the alternatives. Veterans like Russell Wilson and Kirk Cousins were either off the table or provided lower ceilings in terms of potential performance. While younger quarterbacks were available in the draft, such as Shedeur Sanders, the Steelers opted to pass, indicating that they were not convinced any of the prospects could be immediate contributors. Rodgers, by contrast, represents a known quantity with a high upside, even if the median outcome is unremarkable.

Structurally, the Steelers are in a position to support a quarterback like Rodgers. Their defense, ranked 10th in EPA per play in 2024, features elite talent including T.J. Watt, Alex Highsmith, and Minkah Fitzpatrick. Pass protection is also above average, and the offense now boasts wide receiver DK Metcalf, acquired after trading away George Pickens. Though depth at receiver remains a concern, Metcalf offers a big-play threat, and Rodgers could elevate the unit if he meshes well with offensive coordinator Arthur Smith’s system.

However, the risks cannot be overlooked. Rodgers has shown resistance to adapting to new offensive schemes, and Arthur Smith’s system relies heavily on play-action and under-center concepts—styles Rodgers has historically avoided. There is also potential for friction with Metcalf, who is not known for precise route-running, a trait Rodgers demands from his receivers. Moreover, this signing delays the Steelers’ long-term quarterback development plan and could result in another QB search as early as 2026. Financially, the move is reasonable. If Rodgers is indeed playing on a deal around $10 million, the team has preserved its salary cap flexibility. Given this relatively low cost, the potential reward—if Rodgers reaches even 80% of his MVP-level performance—justifies the risk. The Steelers are not mortgaging their future; they are taking a one-year shot while their core players are still in their prime.

The Aaron Rodgers signing by the Pittsburgh Steelers is neither a clear misstep nor an obvious masterstroke. It is a rational move made by a team that understands its window for contention is narrow and fleeting. Whether the gamble pays off will depend on Rodgers’ health, willingness to adapt, and ability to build chemistry within the offense. For now, it’s a bet on upside, and in today’s NFL, that can be enough.