Bellinger’s Free Agency Puts Yankees and Mets in Competition.

Cody Bellinger remains one of the most intriguing free agents on the market, with the New York Yankees and New York Mets both viewed as realistic landing spots. After a strong 2025 season in the Bronx, Bellinger has taken a measured approach to free agency, knowing this contract may be the most significant of his career. Bellinger, now 30, benefited from playing at Yankee Stadium, where he delivered one of his most productive seasons in recent years. Appearing in 152 games, he recorded a .272 batting average along with 29 home runs, 98 runs batted in, and 89 runs scored. His performance reinforced his value as both a reliable hitter and a versatile defender. SNY analyst Dani Wexelman emphasized that Bellinger is an ideal fit for the Yankees, particularly due to his ability to protect Aaron Judge in the lineup. Speaking on MLB Network Radio, Wexelman highlighted Bellinger’s defensive flexibility, noting that his ability to play both infield and outfield positions provides manager Aaron Boone with valuable lineup options. According to Wexelman, players with that level of versatility are difficult to replace. The possibility of Bellinger leaving could increase expectations for Ben Rice, who is currently projected to hit behind Judge. While Rice showed promise with 26 home runs last season, Wexelman expressed concerns about his defensive readiness at first base and questioned whether he can immediately provide the same level of offensive threat as Bellinger. She acknowledged Rice’s potential but suggested that a player of Bellinger’s caliber offers a more complete solution for a contending team.

Meanwhile, the Mets have also emerged as a serious contender. MLB.com writer Andrew Simon suggested that Bellinger’s skill set aligns well with a Mets roster that lost several key contributors. His ability to cover center field, left field, and first base would address multiple needs while strengthening a defense that struggled during the 2025 season. Simon added that signing Bellinger would not only improve the Mets but also weaken a division rival.

As free agency continues, Bellinger’s decision could have a significant impact on the balance of power in New York. Whether he stays in the Bronx or crosses town to Queens, his next contract is expected to shape the direction of whichever team secures his services.