Six Unconventional Quarterback Options for the Broncos Following Bo Nix’s Injury.

The Denver Broncos advanced to the AFC Championship Game for the first time in a decade after a dramatic 33–30 victory over the Buffalo Bills. However, the celebration was short-lived. Head coach Sean Payton confirmed after the game that rookie quarterback Bo Nix fractured a bone in his ankle and will miss the remainder of the season. With their starting quarterback sidelined at the most critical point of the year, the Broncos suddenly face one of the most precarious quarterback situations in recent playoff history. Denver is expected to turn to Jarrett Stidham as its starter, despite the fact that he has not thrown a regular-season pass since January 7, 2024. By the time the AFC Championship kicks off, Stidham will have gone more than two years without live NFL action. His career record as a starter stands at 1–3, while the only other quarterback on the roster, Sam Ehlinger, is 0–3 in three career starts. Given these limitations, it is reasonable to assume that Payton may explore unconventional alternatives beyond the current depth chart. Because Denver needs a quarterback for, at most, one or two games, the situation could appeal to a veteran or even a retired player seeking a short-term opportunity at a championship run. The following quarterbacks represent speculative but intriguing possibilities, listed roughly in order of most recent NFL action. One of the most realistic options is

Ryan Tannehill, who last played during the 2023 season. At 37 years old, Tannehill brings recent experience and postseason credibility, having led the Tennessee Titans to the AFC Championship Game in 2019 and earning Comeback Player of the Year honors that same season. Though Tannehill has publicly suggested his playing days may be over, a sudden opportunity to start an AFC title game could prompt reconsideration.

Another possibility is Matt Ryan, the former league MVP who last played in 2022. Now 40, Ryan recently accepted a front-office position with the Atlanta Falcons, making a return unlikely. Still, the chance to compete for his first Super Bowl ring—especially after enduring multiple historic playoff collapses—could be tempting under the right circumstances.

Cam Newton, the 2015 NFL MVP, has not appeared in a game since 2021 but remains physically capable and has not officially retired. Newton has stated publicly that he would be open to returning if given a legitimate opportunity. His familiarity with Sean Payton’s teams and his experience in high-pressure postseason environments make him a compelling, if risky, candidate.

Perhaps the most emotionally significant name is

Drew Brees, Payton’s longtime quarterback in New Orleans. While Brees has been candid about the decline of his throwing arm and retired after the 2020 season, the deep trust and shared history between coach and quarterback could at least justify a phone call—even if a comeback remains improbable.

Another long-shot option is Andrew Luck, who retired unexpectedly in 2019. Now serving as Stanford University’s football general manager, Luck has expressed contentment with life away from the NFL. Nevertheless, Denver’s organizational ties to Stanford and the limited physical commitment required for a one-game return could make the conversation worth having.

Finally, Colin Kaepernick remains the only player on this list actively campaigning for a return to professional football. Although he last played in 2016, Kaepernick has maintained his training regimen and brings significant playoff experience, including a Super Bowl appearance. While his absence from the league raises questions, his athleticism and big-game résumé could appeal to a team with little to lose. Ultimately, the Broncos may choose stability over spectacle and proceed with Stidham. However, given the stakes and the rarity of this opportunity, Sean Payton may feel compelled to consider every possible option—even those that seem far outside conventional thinking.